December 2020
Unlocking a Catalytic Pathway to Biobased Maleic Anhydride
A major hurdle in large-scale biofuels deployment is the necessary extensive chemical upgrading of intermediates derived from biomass feedstocks. Such biomass refining technologies are nascent or in conceptual stages. In contrast, crude oil is peerless as a feedstock for liquid fuels, and petroleum refining is mature and optimized.
Nonetheless, a few opportunities do exist for the industrial utilization of biogenic carbon. One such area is the synthesis of oxygenated hydrocarbons. Oxygenates play a key role in petrochemicals, and they are expensive to produce via relatively nonselective oxidative functionalization of hydrocarbons. However, the oxygen and reactivity that are inherent in biomass can be leveraged to produce the same chemical species.
Generally, as the oxygen content in a chemical increases, biomass becomes more attractive as a feedstock. Of course, a facile synthetic pathway alone is not sufficient; chemicals are only viable commercial targets when demand exists. However, if a biobased technology can satisfy the dual criteria of competitive advantage and robust market, there is potential for near-term deployment.
Along these lines, a team from Syracuse Univ., funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF), elucidated a strategy for the production of biobased maleic anhydride. The strategy uses supported vanadium oxides to convert levulinic acid, a sugar derivative, into maleic anhydride at around 75% yield. “For this to work, you have to selectively break the terminal C-C bond in a methylketone, which is not generally observed in gas-phase oxidations,” says Jesse Bond, professor of biomedical and chemical engineering at Syracuse Univ.
To explain the unexpectedly high yields of maleic anhydride, the team — led by Ran Zhu — considered aerobic, oxidative scission reactions for a family of substrates (1). Through detailed analysis of selectivities, reaction kinetics, vibrational spectra, and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra, they were able to map the levulinic acid oxidation pathway and identify maleic anhydride as a quaternary product.
The high selectivity toward maleic anhydride stems from levulinic acid’s bifunctionality. Specifically, it is a γ-ketoacid, so it dehydrates to form α- and α′-angelica lactones, which isomerize to a thermodynamically favored β-isomer. Once formed, β-angelica lactone undergoes facile, irreversible oxidative dehydrogenation to form protoanemonin, a conjugated diene. Given its structure, protoanemonin is susceptible to oxidative scission only at its terminal, C4-C5 bond, so it forms maleic anhydride exclusively upon oxidation. High maleic anhydride selectivity in this system thus arises from a cascade of kinetically and thermodynamically favorable reactions that are unique to levulinic acid.
In addition to building mechanistic insights, the researchers made a serendipitous discovery: protoanemonin is a sufficiently stable intermediate in this sequence that it can be isolated in appreciable yields (50–60%) under certain reaction conditions. This is a potential opportunity for biochemical producers.
Protoanemonin is a novel heterocycle with lactone and diene functions, which may have applications in polymer synthesis. Importantly, protoanemonin can be produced, in tunable quantities, alongside maleic anhydride by simply changing the residence time. Selectivity to protoanemonin peaks at residence times below 40 min (at 277°C) (1). Beyond this, selectivity shifts to the thermodynamically favored maleic anhydride.
John Regalbuto, Director of the Center for Rational Catalyst Synthesis, commented: “In his recent papers unveiling the production of maleic anhydride from already-oxygenated biomass as an alternative to oxygenating butane, Prof. Bond indeed demonstrates a biomass conversion process with a competitive advantage and a robust market. The catalysts employed are simple and cheap, which can only enhance the product’s commercial potential.”
1. Zhu, R., et al., “Understanding the Origin of Maleic Anhydride Selectivity During the Oxidative Scission of Levulinic Acid,” ACS Catalysis, 10 (2), pp. 1555–1565 (2020).
This research was funded through the Catalysis Program at the NSF Division of Chemical, Bioengineering, Environmental and Transport Systems (CBET).
This article was prepared by the National Science Foundation in partnership with CEP.